- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
It’s 10:17 at night. A homeowner is standing in a puddle next to the water heater, phone in one hand, thumb hovering over your website. Your office closed three hours ago. The next thirty seconds decide whether that job is yours — or the competitor’s.
That’s the promise every chatbot vendor sells contractors. We researched six tools — published pricing only — and dug into the conversion data to answer the real question: does a chat widget produce booked jobs, or just tire-kicker questions? Honest answer: chat helps when it’s wired into your calendar and followed up fast. As an unstaffed widget, it dies quietly.
The short version
- Nobody to answer chats? Collect.chat Standard $29/month — rules-based quote capture that works at 2 a.m. with zero staff.
- You answer your own messages between jobs? Zoho SalesIQ Basic $10/month — live chat plus a chatbot, the cheapest hybrid.
- Want chat to book jobs? GoHighLevel Starter $97/month — chat wired into its booking calendar.
- Like building flows, may add WhatsApp? Landbot Starter $45/month — best visual flow builder here.
- Want live chat plus AI? Tidio Starter $29/month — Lyro AI is a separate ~$32.50/month add-on. Price the stack.
- Already on Intercom? Essential $29/seat/month — powerful, and the priciest widget here.
Our verdict: A chatbot is a front door, not a receptionist. Nobody watching the site? Collect.chat Standard $29 captures quote requests on autopilot. Answer your own messages between jobs? Zoho SalesIQ Basic $10/month is live chat plus a bot for less than lunch. Want booked jobs? GoHighLevel Starter $97 is the only pick where chat, calendar and follow-up SMS live in one place.
The evidence: does chat actually convert?
The data, from industry studies compiled in 2026: businesses adding live chat see roughly a 20% conversion lift (Invesp, via LiveChat’s report). Visitors who chat are about 2.8x more likely to convert (ICMI, citing Forrester). And 38% of customers are more likely to buy after a positive chat experience.
Two caveats. Almost all these stats come from ecommerce, not contractors — nobody has published chatbot-to-booked-job rates for plumbers. And what transfers isn’t “chat”, it’s speed: reply within five minutes and you’re dramatically more likely to qualify a lead than after thirty (the widely cited InsideSales/HBR finding).
CallRail’s 2025 survey: 24% of callers try chat when a call goes unanswered — chat is the backup channel for phone failures, and we’ve priced five AI receptionists for plumbers here. Phones convert 10–15x better than forms (Invoca).
Where chat wins vs. fails: quote requests, tune-up bookings, “do you service my area” — the considered stuff. Emergencies are different: a burst-pipe homeowner at midnight wants a voice, and a bot that can’t hand off to a phone number in one tap adds friction.
The six tools, honestly compared
Tidio — the small-business default ($29+/mo, AI extra)
Tidio is the most common small-business chat widget: conversations, not seats. Starter: $29/month ($24.17 annual) for 100 billable conversations; Growth from $59/month for 250; free plan covers 50. The catch: the headline covers only human-handled conversations. Lyro AI is a separate add-on from ~$32.50/month on annual billing (50 AI conversations); rule-based Flows another from ~$29/month.
✓ 10 seats on every plan — office and owner share one bill
✓ Real free plan (50 conversations/month)
✗ AI and automation are separate add-ons
✗ Per-conversation pricing punishes busy months
Collect.chat — the no-staff lead catcher ($14–$29/mo)
Collect.chat is a conversational form, not a chatbot — a question-by-question flow capturing name, service type, ZIP and phone. No live inbox, no AI: pure rules-based trees. Free (100 responses/month), Lite $14/month on annual billing (1,000), Standard $29/month annual (unlimited), Unlimited $149/month. Plugs into Google Sheets, Slack, email and Zapier (2,000+ apps).
✓ $29/month for unlimited responses — cheapest serious plan here
✓ Works at 2 a.m. with zero staff
✗ No live chat — a homeowner who wants a human hits a wall
✗ Off-script questions get a shrug
Landbot — the flow-builder pick ($36–$45/mo)
Landbot is for whoever enjoys designing the conversation: a visual canvas for the whole quote-capture flow, with an AI agent block from Starter. Sandbox is free (100 chats/month, no AI). Starter $45/month ($36 annual): 500 chats, 100 AI chats, 2 seats, human takeover. Professional $110/month ($88 annual): 2,500 chats, 300 AI chats, 3 seats, webhooks and API. Overages are published ($0.05/chat, $0.10/AI chat).
✓ Best visual builder here — flows and AI on one canvas
✓ Free sandbox that never expires; 14-day trial, no card
✗ Hand-designed flows — setup takes real time
✗ Removing branding needs the $110 Professional plan
Zoho SalesIQ — the budget hybrid ($7–$12.75/operator)
Zoho SalesIQ is the price disruptor. Free ($0, 100 sessions/month, no chatbot); Basic $7/operator/month on annual billing ($10 monthly) with one chatbot; Professional $12.75/operator annual ($17 monthly) with five chatbots and unlimited operator sessions. For a solo operator, $10/month buys live chat, a chatbot, visitor tracking and lead scoring — no per-conversation meter. Plays nicest inside Zoho’s ecosystem.
✓ Cheapest real hybrid: live chat + chatbot from $10/month
✓ No per-conversation meter — predictable bill
✗ Priced per operator — grows with headcount
✗ Chatbot AI is stronger inside Zoho’s own ecosystem
GoHighLevel — the one that books ($97/mo + usage)
GoHighLevel isn’t a chatbot company; its webchat widget is one piece of the $97/month Starter plan — CRM, pipelines, review requests, missed-call text-back. That’s the booking pick: chat, calendar and follow-up SMS in one system, so a quote request becomes a scheduled job with no Zapier chain. SMS/voice usage meters on top (~$15–$40/month typical). We compared its booking calendar against dispatch-focused apps here.
✓ The only pick where chat writes into your booking calendar
✓ Follow-up SMS in the same $97 — no chatbot-to-CRM gap
✗ $97 is the whole platform — overkill for a widget alone
✗ It wants to BE your CRM, not sync with Jobber or Housecall Pro
Intercom — the grown-up, priced like one ($29+/seat/mo)
Intercom’s Messenger is excellent; its Fin AI agent resolves a reported ~51% of inquiries out of the box. It’s also the priciest widget here: Essential $29/seat/month on annual billing ($39 monthly); Advanced $85 ($99); Expert $132 ($139) — plus Fin at $0.99 per resolved outcome on top. 14-day trial, no permanent free plan. A busy site can generate hundreds of outcomes a month.
✓ Best-in-class AI resolution and a polished widget
✓ Strong automation, reporting and integrations
✗ Per-seat plus $0.99 per AI outcome — the bill scales two ways
✗ No free plan; overbuilt for “capture quote requests”
Feature matrix
| Feature | Tidio | Collect.chat | Landbot | Zoho SalesIQ | GoHighLevel | Intercom |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan worth testing with | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Live human chat inbox | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| AI chatbot built in | ◐ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ◐ | ✓ |
| Rules-based lead-capture flows | ◐ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ◐ |
| Books straight into a calendar | ◐ | ◐ | ✓ | ◐ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Works at 2 a.m. with nobody watching | ◐ | ✓ | ✓ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ |
| Follow-up SMS in the same tool | ◐ | ✗ | ◐ | ◐ | ✓ | ◐ |
◐ = partial — needs a paid add-on, an integration, or a higher tier. Prices are month-to-month rates unless noted, checked October 24, 2026.
What a chatbot must do to actually book jobs
The part most roundups skip — and the whole answer to the title question. A widget doesn’t book jobs. Four things do:
1. Capture the right data. Service type, ZIP, a photo, a name and a phone number. A bot that collects “how can I help?” and emails a transcript is a slower contact form. Rules-based tools never forget the phone number.
2. Check a live calendar. “We’ll call you back” loses to “pick Tuesday 9–11 a.m.” Only GoHighLevel does this natively here. The uncomfortable finding: not one of the six plugs natively into Jobber or Housecall Pro — every sync runs through Zapier or a webhook. We’ve compared the under-$100 CRMs these leads land in here.
3. Follow up in minutes, by text. The chat got the lead; the text saves it. The five-minute window is the biggest lever in lead conversion — and where most contractors fail, because the bot captured the number at midnight and nobody texted until morning.
4. Hand emergencies to a human. “Water is pouring through my ceiling” should never get a bot tree. One tap to call, or instant handoff to whoever’s on call — this rule outranks all the pricing math above.
What you’ll actually pay: solo plumber vs 5-person HVAC company
Solo plumber, ~80 chats a month: $10 (Zoho Basic) to $45 (Landbot Starter), with Collect.chat’s $29 buying unlimited rule-based capture on annual billing. 5-person HVAC company, ~250 chats: Zoho Professional for two operators is $34/month, while Intercom lands near $177 once Fin outcomes are counted. Two traps: Tidio’s headline prices cover only human-handled conversations (AI and automation are separate meters), and Collect.chat’s headline rates are annual-billing prices.
Which should you pick? Answer 3 questions
| Your situation | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Solo, nobody to answer chats | Collect.chat $29 | Rule-based capture at 2 a.m., zero staff. |
| You answer between jobs | Live chat plus a bot — cheapest hybrid. | |
| Chat must book into the calendar | GoHighLevel $97 | Chat, calendar and follow-up SMS in one tool. |
| Love designing flows, may add WhatsApp | Landbot $45 | Best visual builder here. |
| Want live chat + AI, hate per-seat math | Tidio $29 | Per-conversation pricing; add Lyro AI (~$32.50) later. |
| Already run support on Intercom | Intercom $29/seat | Excellent, and the priciest widget here. |
1. What should the chat actually DO?
Capture quote requests while I’m on a job → Collect.chat Standard $29. Answer questions, humans as backup → Tidio Starter $29. Book jobs into my calendar → GoHighLevel Starter $97.
2. Who answers when the bot can’t?
Nobody → rules-based lead-capture bot, not AI promises. Me or the office → live chat with AI assist (Zoho Basic $10/month). Nobody ever available → pair any bot with an answering service — we compared five here.
3. How many chats a month?
Under 100 → free tiers work. 100–300 → Tidio Growth $59 or Landbot Starter $45. 300+ → watch per-conversation meters; Zoho Pro $34 for two operators.
FAQs
Will a chatbot book emergency jobs, or just collect tire-kicker questions?
The phone still books emergencies — a burst-pipe caller at midnight wants a voice, not a bot tree. Chat earns its keep on considered work: quote requests, tune-ups, “do you service my area” — and as backup when calls go unanswered (CallRail 2025: 24% of callers try chat next). Always include an escape hatch: one tap to call the on-call number.
AI chatbot or rules-based — which books more for a small shop?
Rules-based wins when nobody’s watching: it never forgets the phone number and never invents a price. AI shines with a human nearby to catch the handoff. Can’t staff the inbox? Buy the rules bot.
Is a free chatbot plan enough to start?
Yes, as a contact-form replacement — up to roughly 100 chats a month. The caps are the catch: the month chat starts working is the month you outgrow the free tier — and $10–$29/month solves that.
Prices checked October 24, 2026 against vendor pricing pages and current 2026 breakdowns. Collect.chat rates are annual-billing prices.
FREE TOOL
What does an AI receptionist really cost? Headline prices mislead — billing models differ (per minute, per call, per caller). Our true-cost calculator runs your real call volume through each model so you can compare like with like.
Affiliate links coming soon — when we add them, they’ll be clearly labeled, and our picks won’t change because of them.
Comments
Post a Comment